If your furnace is over 15 years old or struggling to keep up, it may be time for a replacement. But with so many models on the market, how do you know which one is best for your home?
At Affordable Comfort, we specialize in high-efficiency Trane systems, known for their reliability and performance. To add value and transparency, we’ve combined our hands-on experience with insights from Consumer Reports and recent efficiency standards to guide your decision.
Top 10 Furnace Brands of 2025 (Based on Consumer Reports Reliability & Satisfaction Ratings)
Consumer Reports regularly surveys thousands of homeowners to evaluate furnace brand reliability and satisfaction. View their full ratings here.
Consumer Reports tracks owner satisfaction and repair history to determine which furnace brands are the most dependable. Here are the top-rated brands as of 2025:
- Trane
Reliability: Excellent
Owner Satisfaction: Very Good
Known for: Long-term durability, energy efficiency, quiet performance - Payne
Reliability: Excellent
Owner Satisfaction: Good
Known for: Budget-friendly reliability, no-frills efficiency - American Standard
Reliability: Very Good
Owner Satisfaction: Very Good
Known for: Shared engineering with Trane, premium efficiency - Bryant
Reliability: Very Good
Owner Satisfaction: Good
Known for: Solid build quality and mid-range pricing - Carrier
Reliability: Very Good
Owner Satisfaction: Good
Known for: Innovative features and efficiency options - Lennox
Reliability: Very Good
Owner Satisfaction: Good
Known for: Energy-saving models, advanced controls - Rheem
Reliability: Very Good
Owner Satisfaction: Good
Known for: Cost-effective, efficient, and dependable - Ruud
Reliability: Very Good
Owner Satisfaction: Good
Known for: Consistent performance with value pricing - Amana
Reliability: Good
Owner Satisfaction: Very Good
Known for: Strong warranties and solid performance - Goodman
Reliability: Good
Owner Satisfaction: Good
Known for: Affordable and widely available systems
Our Top Furnace Pick: Trane S9V2-VS Gas Furnace
Best for: Long-term durability, efficiency, and comfort in Canadian climates
AFUE Rating: Up to 97%
Key Features:
- Two-stage gas valve
- Variable speed ECM blower motor
- Fully insulated cabinet for quiet operation
- ENERGY STAR® qualified
Why we recommend it: This model is one of the most efficient Trane furnaces on the market and well-suited for the Canadian requirement of minimum 92% AFUE. Its variable speed motor provides excellent humidity control and quieter operation, making it a smart long-term investment for energy savings and comfort.
Also Recommended: American Standard Gold 95v Furnace
Best for: Premium performance with shared Trane technology
AFUE Rating: Up to 97% Key Features:
- Variable speed blower
- Consistent Comfort™ technology
- Quiet and efficient operation
Why we recommend it: American Standard and Trane are manufactured by the same parent company and offer nearly identical quality and performance. This model delivers excellent value and is well-reviewed by homeowners in Consumer Reports for comfort and efficiency.
What AFUE Rating Should You Look For in Canada?
In Canada, furnaces must meet a minimum of 92% AFUE. Here’s what those ratings mean:
- 92–95% AFUE: Meets Canadian efficiency standards, suitable for most homes
- 96–98% AFUE: Premium high-efficiency furnaces with advanced features and greater long-term savings
Choosing a furnace with higher AFUE ensures lower heating bills and qualifies for rebates or incentives in many provinces.
Why We Stand Behind Trane Furnaces
We’ve installed and serviced many brands, but Trane stands out for its durability, innovative design, and industry-leading warranties. With proven results in cold-weather climates like ours, Trane furnaces offer peace of mind backed by real performance.
Not Sure Which Furnace Is Right for You?
We take the guesswork out of furnace selection. Our team will assess your home’s needs and recommend models that meet both your comfort goals and your budget.
